Parenting : When the mindset needs to change, from full of complaints to full of thanksgiving
…
count your blessings, name them one by one
count your blessings see what God has done
count your blessings, name them one by one
count your many blessings, see what God has done
…
Singing the above song obviously is so much easier than putting it into practice. For us adults, and especially for little children.
[Get ready for a really long post]
In the past 2 weeks or so, Anya has somehow gotten into the habit of comparing what others have that she DOESN’T have.
Every single day, I’d hear sentences like,
‘Ugh. She has a drawing book with a Mickey Mouse cover on it. How nice. I don’t even have one!’
‘Vai gets to drink the juice first, how nice! And I have to wait!’
‘That boy gets to sit near the bus window. SO comfortable. I don’t even get a seat!’
[Btw, she speaks in Indonesian, and if you understand the language basically this is what she OFTEN says, ‘Enak amat dia … , Anya ajah ga ada …’]
And when she starts her ‘complaining mode’, I explain and emphasise these points to her :
– Everyone is special and we can’t expect everyone to be the same.
Other people have things that we don’t have. That’s for sure. And we also have things that other people may not have (I’d then give real examples of the things that she can be grateful about, things that she has that others may not have)
– If we compare ourselves with others AND complain about what we DON’T have, the list will be ENDLESS.
And everywhere we go and whatever we see, we’d think and say, ‘Ugh look, she has a car, how convenient, I don’t even have one. Ugh look, her pencil is so cute, how nice, I don’t even have one like that. Her birthday cake has nice candles, how lucky, I didn’t even have those for my birthday’ blah blah blah.
What kind of a life would we have if that’s how we think about everything that we see around us. It’s destructive and is so unappreciative of the many blessings we ALREADY have and receive.
– We should seriously change and reverse the way we think and see things, because really, when we utter words and maintain such a mindset it will do us NO good at all.
Instead of saying, ‘Ugh … look at her new bike! How lucky of her. She has a bike like that, and I don’t even have one like hers!’, we can say, ‘Look Mommy, her bike is so nice. I have one at home too!’
And, instead of saying, ‘They all went to Malaysia for their holiday. How nice! I didn’t even go anywhere!’, she can instead learn to say something like, ‘Oh they went to Malaysia… Mommy, can we perhaps go to Malaysia too one day?’ The first sentence is full of envy and complaints. The second is an observation of what other people experience and a pure request. Two completely different approach to a situation. And it all must start from a change in our mindset.
– We really need to count our blessings. We must not see (and complain about) what we don’t have, and we must be thankful for what we ALREADY have
…
Despite my reminders and explanations, Anya finds it hard to stop complaining.
Here’s one episode that I’d like to share with you.
Just three days ago, we were getting ready to go out, and as I placed the kids’ going-out clothes on my bed (for them to get changed by themselves), I heard her mumbled, ‘Vai gets to wear a new top. How nice! I don’t even have anything new!’
And I thought, this is it. She needs to ‘experience’ a lesson.
I walked back to the room (I was on my way out when I overheard her complaints) and casually asked,
You said you have NO new clothes?
No.
I gave you a new little top yesterday, the one you liked and immediately put on when we went out. But you just said you ‘never’ get anything new? As I always say to you, we need to be responsible with what we say and do, right? So, since you said you have nothing new, I’ll keep that top in the storeroom.
[I casually walked out to the kitchen, and she slowly followed]
She then said, “Mommy … err … I want that top’
I continued with what I was doing in the kitchen, giving little response to her plea. Then after a minute or so, I walked back into the bedroom, folded the new top I gave to Anya, and put it in the storeroom.
When she saw how I actually carried out what I said I would do, she started crying real loudly.
She pleaded and repeatedly asked for her top back. And I casually told her,
‘Anya, you know I always do what I say. And you really need to learn to be thankful with what you have, to stop complaining, and to be responsible with what you say. You complained about having no new clothes, and there is NO new top’.
She wailed even more loudly and kept on asking for her new top back. And so after asking her to listen carefully and stop screaming (because really, how can she listen to what I need to seriously say if she’s screaming and crying so loudly at the same time), I told her,
‘This is what will happen. The new top will still be kept in the storeroom. BUT, if I can see – over a period of a week or more – that you want to learn to stop complaining and change the way you think and see things, then you MAY get your top back. But if you keep on complaining about things, the top will need to be given to someone else, someone who will be THANKFUL for the top.
And eg. if you choose to complain about NOT having toys at all, you will have NO toys as you’ve said it yourself, and you’ll see your many toys and belongings going into the storeroom too.’
[I know she LOVES that new top (which is an important key to making this approach more effective), and I know she knows I mean what I say, ie. I will surely carry out what I say I will do, and if I say I will give the top away, I WILL not hesitate in giving it away]
…
Since that day till today, she complains much LESS frequently. When she begins to say, ‘Ugh. How come he has … ‘, she’d stop her sentence, because I would’ve given her a ‘look’, and she knows what I mean. And at times, when she’s about to say something negative, I’d casually look at her and ask, ‘Yes? Do you wish to complain again?’
…
I really can’t imagine the kind of person Anya will become if I don’t nip this negative habit in the bud.
It was getting more and more serious and I knew I had to do something. And in the end, I decided that giving her a little taste of ‘reality discipline’ should (hopefully) be more effective than giving ‘mere talk and explanations’.
It’s a long process.
But I know she’s learning.
AND really, at the same time, I too am seriously reminded too, about how I really should be thankful to God for everything that I ALREADY have.
To not view things negatively. To avoid complaining about stuff. To use positive words, instead of negative ones.
I have SO many flaws and weaknesses myself that I need to change.
And in my heart, I thank my little girl, for reminding me of such precious lessons in life.
…
count your blessings, name them one by one
count your blessings see what God has done
count your blessings, name them one by one
count your many blessings, see what God has done
…
11 Comments »
Leave a comment!
Nic :
Oh, it was definitely carried out with HEAPS of love from Mommy ๐
I always tell my kids that I never want to discipline them, but there are times when I must, for their own good, and it’s because I love them. I tell them too that I discipline them and not other kids, because as their parent I have THAT responsibility.
Not easy …
……………………………………………………………………..
Cindy Khor :
Thanks HEAPS for the encouraging comments…
……………………………………………………………………..
B :
Thanks heaps for sharing! I like how you put it as ‘long-term gain by putting off immediate gratification’, because yes, that exactly is IT.
And hey, I checked out your site and I love your photography AND the stuff you do with your kids!!
Lisna :
wah, apalagi kalo anak lu udah pada lebih gedean … tougher challenge tuh pasti! Apalagi kalo mereka mulai compare dengan peers dll. Ga ada abis2nya deh …
Semoga lu bisa ada wisdom juga deh utk bisa guide mereka …dan semoga anak2 lu juga mau dengerin parents…
Thanks heaps for sharing!
Maja :
As kids grow, they DO grow further away from us ya … Listening ‘more’ to other people, questioning our decisions, etc etc … It’s sad actually, but oh well … it’s part of them growing up (and somehow it’s just not that easy on us parents too ya …)
…………………………………………………………….
Wavesurfer :
Thanks for sharing.
I think we all do compare ourselves with others ya … consciously and unconsciously. Kind of ‘hard’ not to at times.
I guess, what’s more important is our reaction AFTER we have that mental comparison (ie. ‘what do we think / say / do’).
Like you, I need to remind myself a lot too …
This is really an excellent post, thanks so much for sharing. I totally agree with what Ms Cindy Khor wrote here & I will take note of how to handle this situation should I face this challenge in future.
Great post! So very true everything you have mentioned – i was just at another church (not our usual one) & read on their notice board a really interesting lesson about “What is Your Name?” which is essentially the question “Who are you?” – lots of our pain in life comes from comparing our lives with others & thinking of what we don’t have, what we are not – we can only come into fullness/wholeness when we accept who we are & what we have (all our past, mistakes, blessings, good & bad things etc…) – i need to teach & have been trying to teach Tobias not to compare & complaint as well – he is also at the same stage – this is an excellent example of how to deal with it – Thanks so much ๐
it takes courage to carry thru with a disciplinary plan. I’m constantly challenged to be consistent and hold true to the principle of long-term gain by putting off immediate gratification.
there’s an episode in the 3-2-1 Penguins series about constant complaining (in the show it is referred to as the “seed of discontent” – i like that!), and the cure for this? Thankfulness ๐ When I am in my right mind and not too angry I like to remind my boys about the wisdom in these ideas.
glad to read stories of other moms on a similar journey. especially those in singapore. tx for sharing your insight.
i think you are really really good in bringing up your children and how you deal with the whole situation… 1 of the reason i love reading your blog is because you are so rational in handling your children that i will take note of them and intended to do the same thing with my future children
Hey that may sound like a harsh lesson, but it’s actually carried out with LOTS of love on the mommy’s part ๐
Well done..I really admire how you handle her. Untung dia emang cinta sama baju barunya yah jadi bisa kena, kalau anak gua mah tiga2nya ngga perduli sama baju baru..anak gua sih biasanya paling suka ngomong temennya holiday pada ke USA, Australia, etc..etc…kadang2 kita sbg orang tua juga suka kasihan sih ya kalau mereka lihat temen2nya bisa kesana kesini, bisa punya ini itu sedangkan mereka tidak punya..kadang bukannya ngga mampu beli, tapi kita kan hrs pikirin yg terbaik buat mereka juga..
Kayak anak gua yg paling gede (sdh umur 11 thn lebih), temen2nya semua punya notebook & hp yg canggih2 (even ada yg pake Iphone) & hampir semua temennya punya account Facebook. Gua sih tetap tdk kasih dia punya FB, buat apa? Tiap hari juga ketemu temen2nya kok di sekolah, ngapain hrs ikut2an punya FB sekedar supaya bisa dibilang anak gaul. Gua jelasin ke dia bahwa FB itu lebih cocok utk org2 yg sdh agak tua (spt kita2 ini) untuk bisa ketemu lagi sama temen2 lama. Kalau buat anak seumuran mrk utk apa? Dan juga anak2 masih kecil begitu kan blm tahu bahayanya FB..dan juga nanti kalau sdh addicted kan malah repot..tdk ada waktu utk belajar lagi. Temen2nya yah suka kata2in deh, bilang “payah amat sih…gitu aja ngga boleh”. Tapi gua tetap bilang nanti kalau dia sdh cukup dewasa baru boleh..
Leonny,
That’s a really firm and excellent disciplinary action that you are taking against Anya. I agree it’s an undesirable habit that must be stamped out as soon as possible.
I don’t deny I tend to compare myself with others around me at times. Thanks for the reminder for me to count my blessings everyday again. ^^
Le, Emang gitu yah kalo udah mulai umur 5/6 tahun. Pertama-tama compare, terus lama-lama, lebih dengerin temennya ngomong daripada mamanya. You’ll see. Tapi emang kita perlu sekali-kali kasih shock-teraphy. I support you 100%